Tony, you would actually lose more rpm on the overshift with taller gearing, the motor would be pulled off peak alot easier the taller the gears are and we only have a 3000rpm power curve here, the peak at 9000rpm. I think what he is thinking he is losing is when the tach falls back on rpm as I am sure its leaving good then loses rpm then climbs back up, from overshifting, and or slipping the belt, a worn secondary spring, slipping the belt in the back can do just that. If he were over geared(ttodeep) he would actuallyover rev badly the more distance he went, as once the clutch has reached its full shift out the speed will stop yet the engine will over rev. The other thing I ask is a playback tach used? as the stocjk tach is pretty small and hard to watch especially 1,200 rpm going down the track not too mention its down by your waist.
Theres alot of differnt ways to clutch a sled, the srx440 is a very frustrating little machine with its narrow peaky power curve, I liked to gear them deep was easier to control it and they went quicker, not faster mph, but quicker, but it also has alot to do with the clutch set up, more gear allows you to use more clutch weight, less gear less weight. The arctic cat secondary was the biggest single improvement I made, it literally made the sled come to life, the springs and helixs you could fine tune any condition you came across.
Phil: I scuff my clutchs with scotchbrite pads, I have heard both sides as you have, its just what worked for me.
for your speed calculator formula you just use:rpm/gr/ x sc/5280=mph @1;1 clutch ratio
RPM;-rpm of the engine
GR;-gear ratio
SC;- sprocket circumference, which is 22.68 on std 9 tooth drivers
/= divide